Wednesday, November 20, 2019

Commuter Rail Musings

Reading a fair bit about commuter rails for work, getting a bit more in-depth than simple curiosity can furnish time for.

First off: The Darwin awards are numerous. The number of people who attempt to drive around lowered railroad gates is staggering. It's a reliable cause of death, as the railroad changes from use by low-speed freight to higher-speed commuter rail. Made worse when some grade crossings aren't signalized, and lack gates. One sad story was of a woman whose car stalled on the tracks, and the sat there, turning the key, until the train hit her.

Second, I find the contracting of commuter rail operations to be a bit obscene. It's like leasing a car--it lowers the up-front and daily cost, but at the end of the day, the purchaser is left with nothing. When talking about a major public investment, this seems a bit....odd. It makes sense in a 'let's try this out' sort of sense, but that implies a possibility of failure. And if leasing the track, it implies that the rolling stock and maintenance facility ought also be leased.

Third, maintaining track is expensive. An off the cuff number for a freight railroad noted that $10,000 per year per track mile was a reasonable estimate. Think of that--60 miles of track implies $600,000 a year, just to maintain to (far lower) freight standards.




Monday, November 18, 2019

Taking houses for BRT

Couple of years back, I worked on the Ogden BRT project. Trying to get the WSU Dee event center was a pain, and a co-worker and I finally suggested that taking a house was necessary.

That iteration of the study didn't pan out, but I guess we broke some sort of dam, because the next study suggested taking 3 houses.

Rule of transit: Be on the way
Rule 2: Don't be IN the way.

Tuesday, November 5, 2019

Another Light Rail Subway

LA is getting a light rail subway. Under construction, right now. Operating in 2022. [1]

Currently, the Gold Line and Blue Line light rail don't actually connect. The Blue Line ends at Metro Center station, and the Gold line goes through Union station. So getting between the two requires a trip on the Red Line Metro. Two transfers.

Seattle has downtown light rail runnel, and Portland has mooted one, downtown. (Portland as the one through the mountain for the Zoo station, but that's not the same thing as a downtown tunnel. Wonder who else has one?

[1] Supposed to be 2020, but guess what? Digging underground is difficult and expensive, especially in a built up urban area full of old foundations, utility conduits, historical resources (1781 founding)....

Friday, November 1, 2019

A lightrail boondoggle?


I love TRAX, but I'm not in love with TRAX at point of the Mountain. I'd love to see Utah County get light rail, and it seems insane that the two might not connect, but.....Eastern draper is a wasteland of single family homes. There is a rail corridor, but no ridership.


The Utah Legislature (made up of developers) would really like to get UTA to provide service to the Prison site, so they can sell it to the Silicon Slopes tech people. (Who, coming from California, really understand the value of proximity to rapid transit).

That said, the western alignment is less cost-effective, per new system rider:

East - $739 million - 33,000 a day = $22k/rider
West - $1200 million - 44,700 a day = $25k/rider

Been having a long series of conversations on Twitter with 'A Bus Rider' (@sp_redelectric), who has been pretty persuasive in articulating the ways in which Portland has overbuilt its rail network: extending light rail to quasi-rural areas, and then building a truly appalling failure of a commuter rail (WES). 

When I think of where I want TRAX to go, it's not to Utah County (FrontRunner has been fine).  And the Provo-Orem BRT (UVX) has been done well, so I can't claim Utah County can't do BRT. They have BRT to a high standard (not the crap BRT of the Salt Lake County MAX). So....does Utah County really need light rail? The rail corridor they have isn't exactly central to anything. Might the be better off with an electrified FrontRunner (as regional rail) and a bunch of local bus?